Criteria and indicators for evaluating the ideas of the 5th Young Scientists Festival

Evaluation criteria

Criteria

Description for the criteria of the idea

Novelty of the idea

Has the idea been proposed nationally and internationally through being a new one?

Originality of idea or design

Is the idea completely innovative and unique?

Innovation and Creativity

Does the idea have a creative presentation of new products?

Presentation Skill

Does the idea answer all the questions clearly and concisely?

Selection of requirements

Are the materials used in the idea appropriate in line with the product efficacy?

Eco-friendly

Is the idea presented and its predictable product eco-friendly? Efficiency: Does the idea meet the needs of the users of that section?

Value Added

Will the idea add value to the available product on the market?

Security

Will the idea have potential risks to users?

Ergonomics of Ethical Principles

Are ethical principles observed in this idea according to the human dimension for people?

Observance of cultural needs

Are the cultural conditions appropriate to the country considered in the design and do not cause complications?

Possibility of production and commercialization

Will it be technologically and economically possible to produce this idea for commercialization?

The assessment form for the indicators of evaluating the Ideas 5th Young Scientists Festival

1. Idea fit and coordination indicator

Indicator

Description of Indicators

0-2.5 Poor

2.5-5 Average

5-7.5 Good

7.5-10 Excellent

Value of Indicators

Sum of Scores

subject of innovation: the description of the general idea, and what advantage has made the service or product or process offered innovative the description of the general idea, and what advantage has made the service or product or process offered innovativly

The degree of relevance of the idea and the level of innovation in the related section

5

Objectives of the presented idea

The degree to which the objectives fit the defined indicators

0-2.5 Poor

2.5-5 Average

5-7.5 Good

7.5-10 Excellent

Value of Indicators

Sum of Scores

Indicators

Is the idea based on scientific principles of the theoretical foundations in the basic sciences?

5

Is the idea in the direction of interdisciplinary science?

3

Idea fitting with the services provided according to the request of the stakeholders

5

Applying new processes in providing technology and services

3

Capability to have ideas for partnerships with small and medium-sized knowledge-based companies

5

Is the idea capable of establishing a knowledge-based company?

5

Use of simulation software in the making of products along with providing new services

3

Quality of ideas to create shorter cycles and provide services to stakeholders

3

Evaluate ideas to reduce repetitive activities

3

Creating ideas and sourcing them from other centers outside the university

2

Innovation with the aim of acquiring knowledge, creating new technologies, and transferring them

3

make of educational aid products in order to generate enthusiasm for creativity and innovation in students and faculty

3

2. Sustainability level indicator and idea details

Indicator

Description of Indicators

0-2.5 Poor

2.5-5 Average

5-7.5 Good

7.5-10 Excellent

Value of Indicators

Sum of Scores

Background: Summary of innovative product, service, and process

How innovative is this idea, does it improve previous products? For example, faster, cheaper, material optimization, use of recycled parts, and low energy consumption

3

Scope: Provide a summary of the origins and development of innovation

Are there new methods of ideas, services and products, new applications for existing ideas, creating valuable intellectual property, major business, and technical benefits?

3

Results: Description of the problem that this innovation is designed to solve

How responsive will the idea be to technology, processes, and activities to optimize potential and added value How responsive will the idea be to technology, processes, and activities to optimize potential and added value

5

Advantages

The degree of competitiveness of ideas in free trade against new ideas

4

Variability and flexibility

the degree of variability in methods and service delivery and its adaptation to existing conditions

3

3. Confirmations

Indicator

Description of Indicators

0-2.5 Poor

2.5-5 Average

5-7.5 Good

7.5-10 Excellent

Value of Indicators

Sum of Scores

Awards and certificates

Obtaining a badge or certificate from scientific and legal authorities in the national arena

3

Publication of scientific works

Will the idea of ​​innovation for the development of the scientific sector be able to publish a scientific work at the international level in the future?

2

Patentability

The quality of the idea and the ability to invent and taking out a patent on it

4

Awards and Certificates

The value of obtaining a badge or certificate from scientific and legal authorities internationally

5

4. Idea Commercialization Indicator and Innovation

Indicator

Description of Indicators

0-2.5 Poor

2.5-5 Average

5-7.5 Good

7.5-10 Excellent

Value of Indicators

Sum of Scores

The potential for idea growth in the existing business system

The potential of this idea and the investment support in it for the business in the future market.

4

Capability to launch innovation and business activities in the current situation

Documents required for market preparation and attract investors

4

Description of the effects of idea generalization

the quality of the idea in promoting the scientific position in the country or the Middle East in terms of increasing revenue, access to new facilities for stakeholders

5

Description of key characteristics of sustainability and its environmental impacts

Expansion of the significance of environmental impacts, such as reducing waste, increasing recycling, use of renewable energy sources

5

Description of other influences of the development of this idea

Tangible effects: Expected businesses, new or developed skills, job security, and new communications.

Intangible effects: Creating a career motivation in using this idea in the path of promoting  entrepreneurship culture

4

Description of the future forecast for the continuous growth and development of this innovation

expanding the centralized and even geographical impacts or other market activities or providing new opportunities for growth in the Middle East

4